Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes stirred significant media attention when their relationship transitioned from professional to personal in November 2022.
He thought he was rescuing a sheep—but it turned out to be something else
This bizarre French customer habit is driving shop owners crazy
Their romantic involvement began in the spring of 2022 while Robach was still legally married to Andrew Shue, and Holmes was married to Marilee Fiebig. At the time, both denied allegations of an affair.
After facing public scrutiny, they both divorced their respective spouses. Following their separations, they openly discussed their new relationship and the ensuing public reaction on their podcast, “Amy and T.J.”
Continue reading to learn more about the evolution of Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes’ relationship and their own statements about their journey together.
September 2020: Beginning of Their Professional Partnership
Holmes joined the “Good Morning America” team as a co-host for the third hour, aptly named “GMA3: What You Need to Know,” in September 2020.
Robach had been anchoring the show since March 2020, initially focusing on the COVID-19 pandemic before the program broadened its scope.
“We really grew to appreciate this opportunity. The show came together naturally, without any forced effort,” Holmes expressed in an interview with Resident Magazine in April 2021.
Over the following two years, their jobs took them to several events, including Queen Elizabeth II’s Platinum Jubilee in London in June 2022 and the Daytime Emmys shortly thereafter.
Nov. 30, 2022: Public Revelation of Romance
Their relationship was revealed to the public when the Daily Mail published photos of them holding hands in New York City in May 2022.
Before this public exposure, they had secretly traveled together to a cottage in upstate New York, where Holmes was caught on camera in a compromising pose with Robach.
Reports by Page Six later confirmed that their romantic involvement began while they were training for the New York City Half Marathon in March 2022.
“They maintained a close on-air rapport, which was to be expected. However, they were extremely cautious about keeping their relationship a secret off-camera. The news of their affair has left ‘GMA’ producers quite surprised,” an inside source disclosed.
Dec. 5, 2022: Temporary Leave from ‘GMA3’
Following the leak of the photos, ABC temporarily removed Robach and Holmes from the air to conduct an investigation into their relationship.
On December 5, 2022, ABC News president Kim Godwin informed the staff that the situation had become a significant distraction both internally and externally.
Although they did not publicly address their relationship before their leave, they alluded to the situation in their final episode on December 2, 2022.
“It’s a shame it’s Friday; it’s been such a fantastic week,” Holmes remarked, with Robach adding, “Speak for yourself. I’m looking forward to the weekend!”
Dec. 28, 2022: Holmes Files for Divorce
Holmes initiated divorce proceedings from Marilee Fiebig after nearly 13 years of marriage on December 28, 2022. They share a daughter, Sabine, born in January 2013.
According to a Page Six source, Fiebig was taken aback by Holmes’ alleged affair, as the couple had been attempting to reconcile after some months of separation.
“She was completely devastated. She had no idea,” an insider revealed.
The divorce between Holmes and Fiebig was finalized in October 2023, while Robach and Shue completed their divorce proceedings in March 2023, having reached an agreement by December 1, 2022.
Jan. 27, 2023: Departure from ‘GMA3’
Robach and Holmes never returned to “GMA3” after their last appearance on December 2, 2022. In January 2023, Page Six confirmed their exit agreements had been finalized, and ABC had informed its staff of their departure.
“After productive discussions with Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes about various options, we mutually agreed that it’s in everyone’s best interest for them to leave ABC News. We appreciate their dedication and contributions over the years,” an ABC spokesperson stated.
Eva Pilgrim, DeMarco Morgan, and Dr. Jennifer Ashton were subsequently announced as their replacements on the show.
January 2023 – January 2024: Displaying Affection Publicly
Despite losing their positions and facing significant backlash, Robach and Holmes seemed more content than ever, engaging in public displays of affection throughout 2023.
They were spotted cozying up at the Atlanta airport and enjoying the holidays together in Miami in December 2022, with Page Six later capturing them passionately kissing during the warm vacation.
Following ABC’s announcement of their departure, they were seen hugging, kissing, and holding hands in Los Angeles in January 2023.
One month later, Page Six captured Holmes in affectionate poses with Robach during a vacation in Mexico in February 2023.
Throughout the year, they continued to be seen kissing and holding hands across various locations, including New York City and California, and were even spotted engaging in playful dancing at a wedding in December 2023.
March 19, 2023: Reuniting at the Half Marathon
In March 2023, Robach and Holmes participated together in the New York City Half Marathon, marking one year since the start of their relationship.
They continued to engage in running events, including the 2023 RBC Brooklyn Half Marathon, the New York City Marathon in November 2023, and the New York City Half Marathon in March 2024.
Aug. 28, 2023: Making It Instagram Official
On August 28, 2023, they officially confirmed their relationship on social media by posting matching black-and-white photos of their shoes.
They captioned their posts, “#nycmarathon2023 .”
October 2023: A Visit to Holmes’ Hometown
Holmes introduced Robach to his hometown of Fayetteville, Arkansas, in October 2023, marking a significant milestone in their relationship.
They shared multiple photos from the weekend, showing them supporting Holmes’ alma mater, the University of Arkansas, at a football game.
“Hog for a night. Dawg for life. #truelove,” Robach captioned a post on Instagram showing two red seats with their names.
Holmes also shared photos of the event, with images of him holding Robach close as they stood on the sidelines.
Nov. 1, 2023: Returning to Work Together
In November 2023, they made headlines again by announcing their return to the workforce with a new podcast titled “Amy and T.J.”
In a statement, they shared that the podcast would cover a range of topics including current events, pop culture, and personal insights.
“‘Amy & T.J.’ will be informative, entertaining, and authentic. It marks the first time we speak publicly about our personal experiences since becoming part of the headlines,” the statement read.
Dec. 1, 2023: Official Red Carpet Debut
The couple made their relationship red carpet official at the iHeartRadio Jingle Ball 2023 in Los Angeles on December 1, 2023.
Dressed in coordinated black outfits, Robach and Holmes were photographed smiling, laughing, and embracing each other.
A few weeks later, their affectionate behavior continued at iHeartRadio’s Jingle Ball 2023 in New York City.
Dec. 5, 2023: Addressing Allegations of Infidelity
On December 5, 2023, Robach and Holmes addressed the scandal surrounding their relationship for the first time on their podcast.
They denied having an affair and clarified that they were already in the process of divorce when their relationship became public.
“We were already separated from our spouses when we were outed as being in a relationship, not as adulterers,” Holmes stated.
Robach shared that she and Shue had been separated for three months before their relationship was exposed, and Holmes had been living apart from Fiebig since the summer of 2022.
During the podcast, Robach became emotional as she recounted the personal challenges they faced due to the backlash. She revealed a particularly distressing moment when she feared for Holmes’ well-being.
“I was terrified. Finding him unresponsive on his bed was horrifying. I was so scared that he had done something drastic,” she recalled.
Holmes admitted to struggling during that period, revealing he had been excessively drinking and consuming edibles.
Despite the hardships, they concluded the episode by affirming their happiness and love for each other.
“Relationships are challenging and imperfect, but we are fighting for our love. I can truly say I have never been happier. I am with my best friend,” Robach expressed.
Dec. 5, 2023: Romantic Developments Among Ex-Spouses
Shortly after Robach and Holmes discussed their relationship publicly, their ex-spouses, Shue and Fiebig, also made headlines with their own romantic involvement.
Sources revealed to Page Six that Shue and Fiebig had been dating for six months after bonding over their shared experiences of being cheated on.
“They’ve found a connection beyond the affair. They share similar values and have moved past the heartbreak. Everyone has moved forward,” an insider commented.
Fiebig and Shue were later seen together at JFK Airport in New York City in January 2024.
Following the news of their relationship, sources indicated that Robach was upset with Shue, believing he intentionally timed the announcement to overshadow her podcast launch.
“She’s convinced he did this to coincide with her podcast debut,” insiders claimed, although another source countered that Shue was not trying to steal the spotlight.
December 2023 – June 2024: Further Revelations on Podcast
Since launching their “Amy & T.J.” podcast in December 2023, the couple has openly shared numerous personal stories and details about their relationship, including their sex life and family dynamics.
In a December 19 episode, they discussed the possibility of marriage, indicating it was under consideration but not rushed.
“We didn’t start this relationship casually; we entered it with the intention of spending our lives together,” Robach explained.
By April, the topic of marriage was still undecided, with Holmes stating they had not yet resolved whether to formalize their union legally.
The couple also talked about their relationships with each other’s children and how their public profile affected their families.
“My daughters were shocked when they learned about us through the tabloids. It was a difficult revelation for everyone,” Robach shared during the same December 19 episode.
She reassured her daughters about her feelings for Holmes, emphasizing the certainty of her emotions.
Two days later, they discussed the ongoing adjustments in their relationships with each other’s children, acknowledging the complexities of transitioning from friends to romantic partners.
“As challenging as it has been for many people in our lives, it’s hardest for the kids, who now see us differently,” Robach noted in a December 21 episode.
She added that they were striving to build and maintain peaceful relationships with the children.
By January 2024, Holmes and Robach reported that blending their families had become more natural, describing it as an “effortless” process after initially struggling to balance their roles as partners and parents.
“It’s been wonderful to see how well Sabine has adapted. Sometimes she’s disappointed if Robach isn’t home because she enjoys her company so much,” Holmes shared during a January 9 episode.
Robach also expressed joy at the growing bond between the three girls, highlighting the easing and normalization of their family dynamics.
Additionally, the couple candidly addressed challenges within their relationship, such as handling disagreements and separations.
In a December 26 episode, Holmes admitted that he tends to withdraw during conflicts, a behavior he acknowledged needing to improve.
“I don’t need an apology or help during those times. I need to work through it, and I’m trying to do it faster,” he explained.
Robach shared that these periods of withdrawal could last up to two days, during which she would prefer an open confrontation rather than the silent treatment.
Holmes further discussed his frustrations with traveling separately, expressing anxiety about not being physically present to support Robach.
“We’ve been through so much together. I get anxious and fearful when we’re apart because I want to be there to protect you if needed. I just don’t like being away from you,” he said in an April 12 episode.
They also talked about their efforts in participating in Dry January 2024, with Robach revealing her previous consumption of over 30 drinks a week in 2023, and Holmes disclosing his intake of 18 drinks per day in the same year.
Nearly two years after their relationship began, Robach shared her indifference toward public opinions about their controversial relationship.
“We know what it’s like to endure darkness and emerge stronger. I thought I had hit rock bottom before, but this experience showed me what rock bottom truly was,” she said on a June 3 episode.
Holmes echoed her sentiments, describing the entire ordeal as both strange and liberating.
October 2024: Moving in Together
In October 2024, Robach moved into Holmes’ apartment in New York City due to a severe cockroach infestation at her own place.
They described the arrangement as a “trial run,” which eventually led to a permanent living situation for the couple.
Oct. 14, 2025: Engagement Announcement
The couple announced their engagement on the October 14, 2025, episode of their podcast.
“We’re excited to share with all of you that we’re engaged, and it’s been about a month now,” Robach revealed, noting that she had worn her engagement ring to public events before officially announcing the news, but it had gone unnoticed.
Holmes discussed how their past experiences influenced their decision to share the news directly with their audience.
“We wanted to inform you all before anyone else could; we’ve learned from past experiences about the importance of controlling our narrative,” he added.
Similar Posts
- Kaia Gerber’s Star-Studded Dating History: From Pete Davidson to Austin Butler
- Suri Cruise Cheers on Mom Katie Holmes at ‘Our Town’ Broadway Finale!
- Meet Jason and Kylie Kelce’s Adorable Family: Wyatt, Elliotte, Bennett, and Finnley
- 2025 Caf Assistance Schedule: Find Out Your Payment Dates!
- Travis Kelce Turns to Taylor Swift’s Tunes for Every Mood, Even the Blues!
Ellis McDowell is a trend analyst with a sharp eye for spotting the next big thing in entertainment. With years of experience in digital media and trend forecasting, Nora tracks the movements of influencers, viral content, and entertainment trends. Her insights help shape the stories that captivate our audience.
